Lineups and Summary
(back to top)
Giants
@ Phillies
Baker Bowl
September 5, 1928
(No Comments)
The information below contains details about the Major League Baseball game between the Philadelphia Phillies and the New York Giants, played on September 5, 1928 at Baker Bowl.
Game Summary
| Date | September 5, 1928 |
|---|---|
| Visiting Team |
New York Giants
|
| Home Team |
Philadelphia Phillies
|
| Winning Pitcher | — |
| Losing Pitcher | — |
| Save | — |
| Game Winning RBI | — |
Game Info
| Date | September 5, 1928 |
|---|---|
| Day of Week | Wed |
| Day / Night | D |
| Visiting Team | New York Giants |
| Home Team | Philadelphia Phillies |
| Visiting Starting Pitcher | Larry Benton |
| Home Starting Pitcher | Claude Willoughby |
| Ballpark | Baker Bowl |
| City | Philadelphia |
| State | PA |
| Attendance | |
| Time of Game | 2 hours |
| Umpires | HP: Bob Hart 1B: Dolly Stark 2B: (none) 3B: Cy Pfirman |
New York Giants Lineup
| Name | Position |
|---|---|
| Jimmy Welsh | Center Fielder |
| Lefty O'Doul | Left Fielder |
| Mel Ott | Right Fielder |
| Freddie Lindstrom | Third Baseman |
| Bill Terry | First Baseman |
| Travis Jackson | Shortstop |
| Shanty Hogan | Catcher |
| Andy Reese | Second Baseman |
| Larry Benton | Pitcher |
| John McGraw | Manager |
Philadelphia Phillies Lineup
| Name | Position |
|---|---|
| Denny Sothern | Center Fielder |
| Fresco Thompson | Second Baseman |
| Chuck Klein | Right Fielder |
| Freddy Leach | First Baseman |
| Cy Williams | Left Fielder |
| Pinky Whitney | Third Baseman |
| Heinie Sand | Shortstop |
| Spud Davis | Catcher |
| Claude Willoughby | Pitcher |
| Burt Shotton | Manager |
All Plays in Game
(back to top)
Giants
@ Phillies
Baker Bowl
September 5, 1928
Top 1
-
Giants, 0 - Phillies, 0
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Welsh vs. Willoughby
Welsh takes first base on ball four. View Play -
Giants, 0 - Phillies, 0
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1--
O'Doul vs. Willoughby
O'Doul hits a line drive into right field for a base hit. Welsh moves to second. View Play -
Giants, 0 - Phillies, 0
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: 12-
Ott vs. Willoughby
Ott strikes out. There goes Welsh. The throw from Davis and Welsh is out. There goes O'Doul. Here's the throw, and he's safe. View Play -
Giants, 0 - Phillies, 0
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: -2-
Lindstrom vs. Willoughby
Lindstrom hits a line drive into left field, out of the reach of Williams. Lindstrom reaches second base with a double. O'Doul scores. View Play -
Giants, 1 - Phillies, 0
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: -2-
Terry vs. Willoughby
Terry hits a line drive into right field for a base hit. Lindstrom scores. View Play -
Giants, 2 - Phillies, 0
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1--
Jackson vs. Willoughby
Jackson hits a ball on the ground towards third. Whitney fields it and throws to first for the out. View Play
Bottom 1
-
Giants, 2 - Phillies, 0
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Sothern vs. Benton
Sothern hits a line drive into left field, out of the reach of O'Doul. Sothern reaches second base with a double. View Play -
Giants, 2 - Phillies, 0
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: -2-
Thompson vs. Benton
Thompson hits a fly ball into center field. Welsh settles under the ball and makes the catch for the out. Sothern tags and moves to third. View Play -
Giants, 2 - Phillies, 0
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: --3
Klein vs. Benton
Klein hits a line drive into right field, out of the reach of Ott. Klein reaches second base with a double. Sothern scores. View Play -
Giants, 2 - Phillies, 1
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: -2-
Leach vs. Benton
Leach hits a line drive into center field, out of the reach of Welsh. Leach reaches second base with a double. Klein scores. View Play -
Giants, 2 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: -2-
Williams vs. Benton
Williams strikes out. View Play -
Giants, 2 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: -2-
Whitney vs. Benton
Whitney hits a fly ball into right field. Ott settles under the ball and makes the catch for the out. View Play
Top 2
-
Giants, 2 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Hogan vs. Willoughby
Hogan takes first base on ball four. View Play -
Giants, 2 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1--
Reese vs. Willoughby
Reese hits a ball on the ground towards short. Sand fields it and throws to second for the out. View Play -
Giants, 2 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1--
Benton vs. Willoughby
Benton hits a ball on the ground towards third. Whitney fields it, throws to second for one, and over to first - double play. View Play
Bottom 2
-
Giants, 2 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Sand vs. Benton
Sand hits a popup, foul, in front of the plate. Hogan settles under it and makes the catch for the out. View Play -
Giants, 2 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Davis vs. Benton
Davis hits a ball on the ground towards the right side of the infield. Reese scoops it up and throws to first for the out. View Play -
Giants, 2 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Willoughby vs. Benton
Willoughby hits a fly ball into right field. Ott settles under the ball and makes the catch for the out. View Play
Top 3
-
Giants, 2 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Welsh vs. Willoughby
Welsh hits a line drive into right field, out of the reach of Klein. Welsh reaches second base with a double. View Play -
Giants, 2 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: -2-
O'Doul vs. Willoughby
O'Doul hits a line drive into right field for a base hit. Welsh moves to third. View Play -
Giants, 2 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1-3
Ott vs. Willoughby
There goes O'Doul. The throw from Davis and he is safe. O'Doul steals second. Welsh scores. View Play -
Giants, 3 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: -2-
Ott vs. Willoughby
Ott takes first base on ball four. View Play -
Giants, 3 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: 12-
Lindstrom vs. Willoughby
Lindstrom hits a ball on the ground towards short. Sand fields it, throws to second for one, and over to first - double play. O'Doul moves to third. View Play -
Giants, 3 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: --3
Terry vs. Willoughby
Terry hits a ball on the ground towards first. Leach scoops up the ball, races to the bag, and beats Terry for the out. View Play
Bottom 3
-
Giants, 3 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Sothern vs. Benton
Sothern hits a ball on the ground towards third. Lindstrom fields it and throws to first for the out. View Play -
Giants, 3 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Thompson vs. Benton
Thompson hits a line drive into center field for a base hit. View Play -
Giants, 3 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1--
Klein vs. Benton
There goes Thompson. The throw from Hogan and he throws it away. That's a stolen base and an error. View Play -
Giants, 3 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: --3
Klein vs. Benton
Klein strikes out. View Play -
Giants, 3 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: --3
Leach vs. Benton
Leach hits a fly ball into right field. Ott settles under the ball and makes the catch for the out. View Play
Top 4
-
Giants, 3 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Jackson vs. Willoughby
Jackson bunts towards the mound. Willoughby fields the ball and throws it to first. Safe. View Play -
Giants, 3 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1--
Hogan vs. Willoughby
Hogan hits a line drive into left field for a base hit. Jackson moves to second. View Play -
Giants, 3 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: 12-
Reese vs. Willoughby
Reese hits a line drive into right field, out of the reach of Klein. Reese reaches second base with a double. Jackson scores. Hogan moves to third. View Play -
Giants, 4 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: -23
Benton vs. Willoughby
Benton hits a ball on the ground towards short. Sand scoops it up and throws to first for the out. View Play -
Giants, 4 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: -23
Welsh vs. Willoughby
Welsh hits a line drive into center field for a base hit. Hogan scores. Reese scores. View Play -
Giants, 6 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1--
O'Doul vs. Willoughby
O'Doul hits a ball on the ground towards the mound. Willoughby fields it and throws to second for the out. View Play -
Giants, 6 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1--
Ott vs. Willoughby
Ott hits a long drive deep into right field. That ball is going, going, gone. A two run home run.. View Play -
Giants, 8 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Lindstrom vs. Willoughby
Lindstrom hits a ball on the ground towards third. Whitney fields it and throws to first for the out. View Play
Bottom 4
-
Giants, 8 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Williams vs. Benton
Williams hits a popup towards short. Jackson settles under it and makes the catch for the out. View Play -
Giants, 8 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Whitney vs. Benton
Whitney hits a ball on the ground towards first. Terry scoops up the ball, races to the bag, and beats Whitney for the out. View Play -
Giants, 8 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Sand vs. Benton
Sand hits a ball on the ground towards short. Jackson scoops it up and throws to first for the out. View Play
Top 5
-
Giants, 8 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Terry vs. Willoughby
Terry hits a ball on the ground towards third. Whitney fields the ball and throws it to first. Safe. View Play -
Giants, 8 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1--
Jackson vs. Willoughby
Jackson bunts towards the mound. Willoughby fields the ball and throws it to first. Safe. Terry moves to second. View Play -
Giants, 8 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: 12-
Hogan vs. Willoughby
Hogan hits a line drive into right field for a base hit. Terry scores. Jackson moves to third. View Play -
Giants, 9 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1-3
Reese vs. Walsh
Augie Walsh now pitching.
Reese hits a line drive into left field for a base hit. Jackson scores. Hogan moves to second. View Play -
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: 12-
Benton vs. Walsh
Benton strikes out. View Play -
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: 12-
Welsh vs. Walsh
Welsh hits a ball on the ground towards first. Leach scoops up the ball, races to the bag, and beats Welsh for the out. Hogan moves to third. Reese moves to second. View Play -
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: -23
O'Doul vs. Walsh
O'Doul hits a popup towards short. Sand settles under it and makes the catch for the out. View Play
Bottom 5
-
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Davis vs. Benton
Davis strikes out. View Play -
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Walsh vs. Benton
Walsh strikes out. View Play -
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Sothern vs. Benton
Sothern takes first base on ball four. View Play -
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1--
Thompson vs. Benton
Thompson hits a ball on the ground towards the mound. Benton fields it and throws to first for the out. View Play
Top 6
-
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Ott vs. Walsh
Ott hits a line drive into left field for a base hit. View Play -
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1--
Lindstrom vs. Walsh
Lindstrom hits a ball on the ground towards third. Whitney fields it and throws to second for the out. View Play -
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1--
Terry vs. Walsh
Terry hits a popup, foul, towards third. Whitney catches it, and throws the ball away attempting to make the double play. Lindstrom moves to second. View Play -
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: -2-
Jackson vs. Walsh
Jackson bunts towards the mound. Walsh fields the ball and throws it to first. Safe. Lindstrom moves to third. View Play -
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1-3
Hogan vs. Walsh
Hogan hits a ball on the ground towards third. Whitney fields it and throws to first for the out. View Play
Bottom 6
-
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Klein vs. Benton
Klein hits a ball on the ground towards the right side of the infield. Reese scoops it up and throws to first for the out. View Play -
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Leach vs. Benton
Leach hits a popup, foul, towards third. Lindstrom settles under it and makes the catch for the out. View Play -
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Williams vs. Benton
Williams hits a line drive into right field for a base hit. View Play -
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1--
Whitney vs. Benton
Whitney hits a ball on the ground towards shortstop. Jackson fields it and races to the second base bag for the out. View Play
Top 7
-
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Reese vs. Walsh
Reese hits a ball on the ground into left center field for a base hit. View Play -
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1--
Benton vs. Walsh
Benton bunts towards first. Leach scoops up the ball, races to the bag, and beats Benton for the out. Reese moves to second. View Play -
Giants, 10 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: -2-
Welsh vs. Walsh
Welsh hits a line drive into right field for a base hit. Reese scores. View Play -
Giants, 11 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1--
O'Doul vs. Walsh
O'Doul hits a line drive into left field, out of the reach of Williams. O'Doul reaches second base with a double. Welsh moves to third. View Play -
Giants, 11 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: -23
Ott vs. Walsh
Ott hits a ball on the ground towards short. Sand fields it, and throws to first. And he throws it away. That's an error on Sand. Welsh scores. O'Doul moves to third. That run is unearned. View Play -
Giants, 12 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1-3
Lindstrom vs. Walsh
There goes Ott. The throw from Davis and he is safe. Ott steals second. View Play -
Giants, 12 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: -23
Lindstrom vs. Walsh
Bill Deitrick now playing shortstop.
Lindstrom strikes out. View Play -
Giants, 12 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: -23
Terry vs. Walsh
Terry hits a fly ball into center field. Sothern settles under the ball and makes the catch for the out. View Play
Bottom 7
-
Giants, 12 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Deitrick vs. Benton
Joe Price now playing center field.
Deitrick hits a ball on the ground towards short. Jackson scoops it up and throws to first for the out. View Play -
Giants, 12 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Davis vs. Benton
Davis strikes out. View Play -
Giants, 12 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Walsh vs. Benton
Walsh hits a fly ball, foul, into right field. Ott settles under the ball and makes the catch for the out. View Play
Top 8
-
Giants, 12 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Jackson vs. Walsh
Jackson hits a popup, foul, in front of the plate. Davis settles under it and makes the catch for the out. View Play -
Giants, 12 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Hogan vs. Walsh
Hogan strikes out. View Play -
Giants, 12 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Reese vs. Walsh
Reese hits a ball on the ground towards first. Leach fields the ball and throws to Walsh covering. Safe. View Play -
Giants, 12 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1--
Benton vs. Walsh
Benton strikes out. View Play
Bottom 8
-
Giants, 12 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Sothern vs. Benton
Jack Cummings now catching.
Sothern hits a popup, foul, towards first. Terry settles under it and makes the catch for the out. View Play -
Giants, 12 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Thompson vs. Benton
Thompson hits a fly ball into right field. Ott settles under the ball and makes the catch for the out. View Play -
Giants, 12 - Phillies, 2
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Klein vs. Benton
Klein hits a long drive deep into right field. That ball is going, going, gone. A home run. View Play -
Giants, 12 - Phillies, 3
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Leach vs. Benton
Leach hits a fly ball into left field. O'Doul settles under the ball and makes the catch for the out. View Play
Top 9
-
Giants, 12 - Phillies, 3
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Price vs. Walsh
Price is called out on strikes. View Play -
Giants, 12 - Phillies, 3
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
O'Doul vs. Walsh
O'Doul hits a line drive into right field, out of the reach of Klein. O'Doul reaches second base with a double. View Play -
Giants, 12 - Phillies, 3
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: -2-
Ott vs. Walsh
Ott hits a long drive deep into right field. That ball is going, going, gone. A two run home run.. View Play -
Giants, 14 - Phillies, 3
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Lindstrom vs. Walsh
Lindstrom hits a ball on the ground towards third. Whitney fields it and throws to first for the out. View Play -
Giants, 14 - Phillies, 3
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Wrightstone vs. Walsh
Russ Wrightstone pinch hits for Bill Terry.
Wrightstone hits a ball on the ground towards first. Leach scoops up the ball, races to the bag, and beats Wrightstone for the out. View Play
Bottom 9
-
Giants, 14 - Phillies, 3
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: ---
Williams vs. Benton
Russ Wrightstone now playing first base. Andy Cohen now playing third base.
Williams hits a line drive into left field for a base hit. View Play -
Giants, 14 - Phillies, 3
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: 1--
Whitney vs. Benton
That is defensive interference on unknown player with unknown particulars. Williams moves to second. View Play -
Giants, 14 - Phillies, 3
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: -2-
Whitney vs. Benton
Whitney takes first base on ball four. View Play -
Giants, 14 - Phillies, 3
Outs: 0, Count: 0-0, RoB: 12-
Deitrick vs. Benton
Deitrick strikes out. View Play -
Giants, 14 - Phillies, 3
Outs: 1, Count: 0-0, RoB: 12-
Davis vs. Benton
Davis hits a ball on the ground towards the mound. Benton fields it and throws to first for the out. Williams moves to third. Whitney moves to second. View Play -
Giants, 14 - Phillies, 3
Outs: 2, Count: 0-0, RoB: -23
Lerian vs. Benton
Walt Lerian pinch hits for Augie Walsh.
Lerian strikes out. View Play
Audio Play-by-Play
(back to top)
Click the button below to listen to the audio play-by-play.
If the player above doesn’t work for you, please check to make sure that your speakers are not muted, especially if your device has a hardware "silence switch".
If that does not resolve the issue, please download the MP3 file below to play the game audio directly.
Box Score
(back to top)
Game of 9/5/1928 -- New York at Philadelphia (D)
New York AB R H RBI Philadelphia AB R H RBI
Welsh J, cf 4 2 3 3 Sothern D, cf 3 1 1 0
Price J, cf 1 0 0 0 Thompson F, 2b 3 0 1 0
O'Doul L, lf 6 3 4 0 Klein C, rf 4 2 2 2
Ott M, rf 5 2 3 4 Leach F, 1b 4 0 1 1
Lindstrom F, 3b 6 1 1 1 Williams C, lf 4 0 2 0
Cohen A, 3b 0 0 0 0 Whitney P, 3b 3 0 0 0
Terry B, 1b 5 1 2 1 Sand H, ss 2 0 0 0
Wrightstone R, ph-1b 1 0 0 0 Deitrick B, ss 2 0 0 0
Jackson T, ss 5 2 3 0 Davis S, c 4 0 0 0
Hogan S, c 4 1 2 1 Willoughby C, p 1 0 0 0
Cummings J, c 0 0 0 0 Walsh A, p 2 0 0 0
Reese A, 2b 5 2 4 2 Lerian W, ph 1 0 0 0
Benton L, p 4 0 0 0
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
46 14 22 12 33 3 7 3
New York 201 520 202 -- 14
Philadelphia 200 000 010 -- 3
New York IP H R ER BB SO
Benton L (W) 9.0 7 3 3 2 7
Philadelphia IP H R ER BB SO
Willoughby C (L)* 4.0 13 10 10 3 1
Walsh A 5.0 9 4 3 0 5
* Pitched to 3 batters in 5th
E -- Hogan S, Whitney P, Sand H
DP -- Philadelphia 3
LOB -- New York 9, Philadelphia 6
2B -- Lindstrom F, Sothern D, Klein C, Leach F, Welsh J, Reese A, O'Doul L 2
HR -- Ott M 2, Klein C
SB -- O'Doul L, Thompson F, Ott M
CS -- Welsh J
SH -- Benton L
SF -- Thompson F
T -- 2:00
A -- 0
More Complete Baseball-Reference Box Score
